Skip to main content

SAT Reading and Writing · Information and Ideas

SAT Command of Evidence

Command of Evidence questions ask which quotation, finding or data point best supports, illustrates or weakens a claim. Some use a table or graph alongside the text.

What to watch for

  • Restate the exact claim before you look at the choices.
  • With data, check that the numbers match both the claim and the time or group it refers to.
  • A choice can be accurate and still fail to support the specific claim.

Worked examples

Example 1

Vitamin C Remaining in Four Vegetables after 7 Days of Storage (percent of original amount)
VegetableRoom temperatureRefrigeratedFrozen
Broccoli416889
Spinach306285
Green beans527480
Peas477192
Vitamin C breaks down over time once vegetables are harvested, so storage conditions affect how much of the vitamin reaches the table. Food scientists measured how much vitamin C four vegetables kept after a week at room temperature, in a refrigerator, or in a freezer. They found that the benefit of freezing over refrigerating was not the same for every vegetable. For example, ______

Which choice most effectively uses data from the table to complete the example?
  1. A.broccoli stored at room temperature kept 41% of its vitamin C, whereas peas stored at room temperature kept 47% of theirs.
  2. B.frozen peas kept 80% of their vitamin C and refrigerated peas kept 71%, whereas frozen spinach kept 85% and refrigerated spinach kept 62%.
  3. C.frozen spinach kept 85% of its vitamin C and refrigerated spinach kept 62%, whereas frozen green beans kept 80% and refrigerated green beans kept 74%.
  4. D.frozen broccoli kept 89% of its vitamin C, whereas frozen peas kept 92% of theirs, the highest share of any vegetable in the study.
Show the answer and explanation

Answer: C

Choice C is the best answer because it shows that freezing's advantage over refrigerating differed between vegetables: frozen spinach kept 85% of its vitamin C versus 62% refrigerated, a large gap, while frozen green beans kept 80% versus 74%, a small one. Choice A is incorrect because, although accurate, it describes room-temperature storage only. Choice B misreads the table: frozen peas kept 92%, not 80%. Choice D is accurate but gives frozen values only, so it can't show how freezing compared with refrigerating.

Example 2

When ocean water becomes unusually warm, corals can expel the tiny algae that live in their tissues and turn white, an event called bleaching. Many bleached corals die, and seaweed often spreads across the dead reef surface, leaving little room for new corals to grow. A team of marine ecologists hypothesizes that parrotfish, which scrape seaweed off rock as they feed, help bleached reefs recover by clearing surfaces where young corals can attach.

Which finding, if true, would most directly support the team's hypothesis?
  1. A.Young corals on bleached reefs with many parrotfish grew at about the same rate as young corals on bleached reefs with few parrotfish.
  2. B.Two years after a bleaching event, reef sections that parrotfish were kept out of by cages had more young corals than sections the fish could reach.
  3. C.After a bleaching event, the number of parrotfish living on bleached reefs was lower than the number living on nearby reefs that had not bleached.
  4. D.Two years after a bleaching event, reef sections that parrotfish could reach had less seaweed and more young corals than sections caged off from the fish.
Show the answer and explanation

Answer: D

Choice D is the best answer because the hypothesis says parrotfish help bleached reefs recover by clearing seaweed so young corals can attach, and this finding shows that sections open to parrotfish had less seaweed and more young corals than caged sections. Choice A is incorrect because it shows parrotfish making no difference. Choice B shows the opposite of the hypothesis: more young corals where parrotfish were kept out. Choice C is about how many parrotfish live on bleached reefs, not what they do there.

Practice command of evidence

More SAT command of evidence questions at every difficulty, with explanations in your language.