Example 1
While researching a topic, a student has taken the following notes:
- Most liquids become denser as they cool.
- Water is unusual: it is densest at about 4°C and becomes less dense as it cools below that temperature.
- In winter, water near 4°C sinks to the bottom of a lake, while colder water stays near the surface.
- That colder surface water is the first to freeze.
- Fish survive the winter in the liquid water beneath the ice.
The student wants to explain why lakes freeze from the top down. Which choice most effectively uses relevant information from the notes to accomplish this goal?
- Most liquids become denser as they cool.
- Water is unusual: it is densest at about 4°C and becomes less dense as it cools below that temperature.
- In winter, water near 4°C sinks to the bottom of a lake, while colder water stays near the surface.
- That colder surface water is the first to freeze.
- Fish survive the winter in the liquid water beneath the ice.
The student wants to explain why lakes freeze from the top down. Which choice most effectively uses relevant information from the notes to accomplish this goal?
- A.Lakes freeze from the top down in winter, and fish are able to survive in the liquid water that remains beneath the frozen surface.
- B.Because water becomes less dense as it cools below about 4°C, the coldest water in a lake stays near the surface, where it freezes first.
- C.Unlike most liquids, which become denser as they cool, water is densest at about 4°C.
- D.In winter, water that is near 4°C sinks to the bottom of a lake.
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: B
Choice B is the best answer. The goal requires a cause, and the sentence links water's lower density below about 4°C to the coldest water staying at the surface and freezing first. Choice A is incorrect because it states that lakes freeze from the top down without explaining why. Choice C is incorrect because it states the density fact without connecting it to freezing. Choice D is incorrect because it explains where the warmer water goes but not why freezing starts at the top.