Example 1
Text 1
For two centuries, a medieval river port in northern Europe thrived on the wool and cloth trade. Then, in the 1400s, its fortunes collapsed. Historian Pieter Claes attributes the collapse to the silting of the river channel that connected the port to the sea: as sand and mud built up, large merchant ships could no longer reach the docks, and trade moved elsewhere.
Text 2
Historian Ines Moreau accepts that the channel silted up and that the port's decline sped up as a result. Yet tax records show that the port's trade had begun falling around 1380, decades before ships had trouble reaching the docks and soon after a rival town was granted the right to hold a major annual fair. Merchants, Moreau argues, had started leaving for reasons that had nothing to do with the river.
Based on the texts, how would Moreau (Text 2) most likely respond to Claes's explanation in Text 1?
For two centuries, a medieval river port in northern Europe thrived on the wool and cloth trade. Then, in the 1400s, its fortunes collapsed. Historian Pieter Claes attributes the collapse to the silting of the river channel that connected the port to the sea: as sand and mud built up, large merchant ships could no longer reach the docks, and trade moved elsewhere.
Text 2
Historian Ines Moreau accepts that the channel silted up and that the port's decline sped up as a result. Yet tax records show that the port's trade had begun falling around 1380, decades before ships had trouble reaching the docks and soon after a rival town was granted the right to hold a major annual fair. Merchants, Moreau argues, had started leaving for reasons that had nothing to do with the river.
Based on the texts, how would Moreau (Text 2) most likely respond to Claes's explanation in Text 1?
- A.By rejecting the idea that the river channel silted up, since the tax records show that large merchant ships kept reaching the docks
- B.By agreeing that silting caused the collapse of the port's trade while suggesting that the rival town later declined for the very same reason
- C.By agreeing that the silting of the channel sped up the decline but arguing that it cannot explain why the port's trade began falling
- D.By arguing that a drop in the demand for wool and cloth, not the silting of the channel, caused the port's decline
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: C
Choice C is the best answer. Text 1 attributes the port's collapse to the silting of its channel. Text 2 agrees that silting sped the decline but notes that trade had started falling around 1380, decades before ships had trouble, after a rival town gained a major fair. Moreau would say silting can't explain the decline's start. Choice A is wrong because Moreau accepts that the channel silted up. Choice B is wrong because Moreau doubts that silting alone caused the collapse, and Text 2 says nothing about the rival town's later history. Choice D names a cause Text 2 never mentions, and Moreau accepts that silting played a role.